Square Pies
Meatfest Square Pie
A little of everything we've got.
$13.99
Cheese Pizza
Sauce and pizza cheese.
$9.99
Veggie Heaven Pie
Tomato, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.
$12.99
Buffalo Chicken Square Pie
Grilled chicken with our hot sauce & our blend of cheeses. Mixed with your choice of ranch or blue cheese.
$12.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Grilled chicken, savory bacon, buttermilk ranch & our blend of cheeses.
$12.99
Philadelphia Pie
Steak, cheese, onions and sweet peppers.
$13.99
Up To 3 Toppings
Sauce and pizza cheese.
$11.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$12.99
BUILD YOUR OWN
Sauce and pizza cheese.
$13.99
Everything Pizza
All of our meats and veggies
$13.99
Pickle Pizza
$12.99
Cauliflower Crust Pies
Cauliflower CHEESE
$10.99
Cauliflower up to 3 Toppings
$11.99
Cauliflower Crust Build Your Own
$12.99
Cauliflower Crust Buffalo Chicken
$12.99
Cauliflower Crust Chicken Bacon Ranch
$12.99
Cauliflower Crust Meatfest
Ham, bacon, sausage, ground beef & pepperoni.
$12.99
Cauliflower Crust Philadelphia
Ranch or pizza sauce. Steak, onions & sweet peppers.
$12.99
Veggie Cauliflower Crust
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and tomatoes
$12.99
Crustless Bowls
Crustless Buffalo Chicken Bowl
$8.99
Crustless Meatlovers Bowl
$8.99
Crustless Veggie Bowl
$8.99
Crustless Supreme Bowl
$8.99
BYO Crustless Bowl
$8.99
Square Cut Deals
10 Cuts Pepperoni Special
With pepperoni only.
$14.49
15 Cuts Pepperoni Special
15 pepperoni cuts.
$19.99
2 Cuts, Side Salad & Fountain Drink Special
Pepperoni cuts.
$8.49
3 Cuts & 16 Fountain Drink Special
Pepperoni cuts.
$5.65
1 Cut of Pepperoni
Pepperoni.
$1.50
7 Cuts Pepperoni Pizza & Two 16oz Drinks Special
7 pepperoni cuts and 2 fountain drinks.
$12.49
Party Box with Pepperoni
28 cuts. 26"x18". Feeds 10-14 people; comes with Pepperoni topping.
$35.99
One Specialty Cut Special
Mon/Fri: Buffalo chicken Tue/Sat: Meat fest Wed: Deluxe Thu/Sun: Chicken bacon ranch
$1.99
3 Specialty Cuts & Drink Special
Mon/Fri: Buffalo chicken. Tue/Sat: Meat fest Wed: Deluxe Thu/Sun: Chicken bacon ranch
$8.29
Snack Pack
2 cuts of pepperoni, 2 breadsticks & fountain drink!
$5.99
Square Deals In Store
2 Cuts, Side Salad & Fountain Drink Special
Pepperoni cuts.
$8.49
3 Cuts & 16oz Fountain Drink
Pepperoni cuts.
$5.65
One Specialty Cut Special
Mon/Fri: Buffalo chicken Tue/Sat: Meat fest Wed: Deluxe Thu/Sun: Chicken bacon ranch
$1.99
Upgrade Drink
$0.40
Sides
Breadsticks
Comes with sauce on the side.
$5.49
Fries
Oven-baked fries.
$3.99
Garlic Cheese Bread
A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack.
$5.99
Pepperoni Bites
$4.99
Cinna Stix
$5.99
Garlic Knots (8)
Our freshly made dough, drizzled with made from scratch garlic sauce. Sprinkled with Parmesan.
$6.99
Extras
Garlic Butter Dipping Sauce
$0.99
Ken's Buttermilk Ranch Dipping Sauce
$0.99
10” & 14” Garlic Crust
$0.99
Party Box Garlic Crust
$1.99
Garlic Parm Cup
$0.99
Wings
Boneless Wings
Sauce on the side.
$8.49
Salads
American Chef Salad
Salad blend with onions, tomatoes, ham, turkey & cheese. The dressing is on the side.
$9.99
Chicken Salad
Salad blend with onions, tomatoes & cheese! The dressing is on the side.
$10.99
Garden Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and cheese.
$7.49
Italian Chef Salad
Salads blend with onions, tomatoes, salami, pepperoni, ham and cheese. The dressing is on the side.
$9.99
Sirloin Tip Steak Salad
Salad mixture, onions, tomatoes & cheese!
$12.99
Side Salad
$4.49
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad
Candied walnuts, cranberries, grilled chicken & feta cheese. Best paired with Raspberry Vinaigrette!
$11.99
Squarebolis
Buffalo Chicken Squareboli
Chicken, cheese and hot sauces.
$8.99
Chicken Squareboli
Green peppers, onions, mushrooms and cheese.
$8.99
Original Squareboli
Ham, pepperoni and cheese.
$7.99
Steak Squareboli
Steak, pepperoni, and cheese.
$8.99
Veggie Sqaureboli
Onions, tomatoes, green peppers, mushroom & cheese.
$8.99
CBR Boli
$8.99
Cauliflower Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
Cheese Steak Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
Ham Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
Turkey Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
All American Club Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
Italian Cauliflower Sandwich
$12.99
Subs
All American Club Sub
Turkey, ham, bacon and cheese.
$5.99
Buffalo Chicken Sub
With ranch or bleu cheese.
$5.99
Cheesesteak Sub
Tasty on its own or add onions and peppers.
$5.99
Meatballs & Mozz Sub
Oven-baked with hearty Italian meatballs, our signature sauce & a mixture of mozzarella and provolone cheese.
$5.99
Turkey Sub
Turkey & cheeses.
$5.99
Ham Sub
Ham & a mixture of cheeses.
$5.99
Grilled Chicken Sub
$5.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
$5.99
Italian Sub
Ham, pepperoni, salami & a blend of our cheeses
$5.99
Pizza Steak
Pepperoni, sauce & cheese
$5.99
Philly Cheese Steak
Onions, green peppers and mushrooms cooked
$5.99
Kid's Meals
One Cut Kids Meal
2 Breadsticks and a drink.
$4.99
Kids Chicken Nuggets
Fries and a drink.
$4.99
Drinks
2-Liters
$3.99
Fountain Drinks
$2.69
Best Way Pizza Alum Bank
Not in the mood to cook? Taste the best pizza in Pleasantville. Pleasantville is home to the ever-popular Best Way Pizza Alum Bank. With great pizzas on the menu, it isn't hard to see why. You'll find more than just pizza at the top restaurants in Pleasantville. Try some of the local top dishes for a treat. Try Meatfest Square Pie and see what all the fuss is about. This local classic has created an enviable reputation over the years. Best Way Pizza Alum Bank has been a Slice partner for years, providing delivery and takeout in the community. Take home your pizza with curbside pickup. It's never been easier to grab a pizza whenever you feel the urge. With multiple locations to serve you, Best Way Pizza Alum Bank makes it easy to get something to eat. Pay by credit card. Keep up with Best Way Pizza Alum Bank on social media.
Full Hours